Research case · Transformation
Defeated in an argument by myself
London, England · 18th century
He dreamed that he had been worsted in a verbal argument, and was thereby much mortified.
Open this dream in the galaxy →
- Source
- The World of Dreams — Havelock Ellis, 1911. Case report
- Rights
- Public domain (US)
- Record type
- Research case
- Place
- London, England
- Cultural context
- British
- Date
- 18th century
- Uncertainty
- Moderate — Samuel Johnson’s dream, quoted by Ellis from Boswell; Johnson noted the winning wit was his own.
- Imagery
- A stranger · Book
- Feelings
- Helplessness
Another way to look at this dream
Notes on the images in this dream from psychology, myth, folklore and semiotics. Each names its source.
A stranger
Did the stranger remind you of anyone, even slightly? What did they want from you?
Jung · Shadow, anima and animus
Jung read unknown figures as possible parts of the dreamer: a same-sex stranger may carry the shadow; an other-sex figure what he called the anima or animus. These are offered as lenses, not labels — and his gender framing reflects his time.
C. G. Jung, “Aion, ch. 2–3”, Collected Works 9ii
Homeric epic Classical text
In Homer, gods and dreams arrive in borrowed shapes: Athena visits Nausicaa disguised as her friend; Zeus sends a Dream to Agamemnon looking like Nestor.
Odyssey VI; Iliad II
Book
Could you read the book? Did it belong to you, or did someone hand it over?
Hebrew prophets Myth & scripture
In a vision Ezekiel is handed a scroll written inside and out with “lamentations, and mourning, and woe”, told to eat it, and finds it “as honey for sweetness”. Taking a text into the body is how the message is received. (A vision, not a dream.)
Ezekiel 2:9–3:3 (King James Version)
Christian scripture Myth & scripture
In Revelation John is told to take a little book from an angel’s hand and eat it: sweet as honey in the mouth, bitter in the belly. The same book is both. (A vision, not a dream.)
Revelation 10:9–10 (King James Version)
Exploration notes, not a diagnosis, a prediction, or evidence of real events.
Dreams that share its images
- My heart’s spirit resigned Ye (Handan), China · c. 560 (Northern Qi)
- Charged one franc of interest Zurich, Switzerland · c. 1914
- Setna’s night with Tabubua Memphis, Egypt · Ptolemaic period (story)
- The five-coloured brush taken back Southern China · c. 500 (Liang)
- A book read during sleep Atcham, England · March 5, 1885
- Trying to take form after death Not stated · January 1878