Research case · Falling & stuck
The scene I had to write
England · before 1911
Thus I imagined I was sitting at a window, at the top of a house, writing. As I looked up from my table I saw… a woman in her nightdress appear at a lofty window some distance off, and throw herself down. I went on writing, however, and found that… the very next thing I had to do was to describe exactly such a scene as I had just witnessed. I was extremely puzzled at such an extraordinary coincidence…
Open this dream in the galaxy →
- Source
- The World of Dreams — Havelock Ellis, 1911. Ch. II
- Rights
- Public domain (US)
- Record type
- Research case
- Place
- England
- Cultural context
- British
- Date
- before 1911
- Uncertainty
- Moderate — Contains a depiction of a fall from a window.
- Imagery
- Writing · Falling · Heights · House · A stranger
- Feelings
- Confusion · Horror
Another way to look at this dream
Notes on the images in this dream from psychology, myth, folklore and semiotics. Each names its source.
Writing
Were you reading the words or writing them? Do you remember anything you could use when you woke?
English Romantic poetry Literature
Coleridge said he fell asleep over a book and, for about three hours, composed two or three hundred lines of “Kubla Khan”, with the images rising “as things”. When he woke and began writing, a person on business from Porlock interrupted him for an hour, and most of the poem was gone.
S. T. Coleridge, preface to “Kubla Khan” (1816)
Victorian fiction Literature
Stevenson wrote that after two days of racking his brains for a plot, on the second night he “dreamed the scene at the window” of Jekyll and Hyde, and the scene where Hyde takes the powder and changes. The rest, he said, he made awake.
R. L. Stevenson, “A Chapter on Dreams”, in Across the Plains (1892)
Falling
Where were you standing before the fall? Were you reaching for something to hold, or letting go?
Jung · Descent
In his memoir Jung describes deliberately “letting himself drop” into an inner depth in 1913, and treated descent as a way of meeting what lies below everyday awareness — frightening, but not only a disaster.
C. G. Jung, Memories, Dreams, Reflections (1962)
Early dream research Dream research
Ellis explained falling dreams through bodily sensations at the edge of sleep. Sleep researchers today describe the related “hypnic jerk”, a sudden start while falling asleep.
Havelock Ellis, The World of Dreams (1911), ch. VI
Classical Chinese medicine Historical medicine
The same passage of the Lingshu pairs flying with falling: when the lower body is in excess, “one dreams of falling”. This is a historical theory about the body, not medical advice and not a way to diagnose anything.
Huangdi Neijing, Lingshu ch. 43 “Yinxie Fameng”
House
Whose house was it — one you know, or one you only know in the dream? Which room did you spend the most time in?
Jung · The house as psyche
In 1909 Jung dreamed of a house whose cellar led down into older and older layers — Roman, then prehistoric. He later took it as an image of the psyche, with the oldest layers at the bottom.
C. G. Jung, Memories, Dreams, Reflections (1962)
Phenomenology Philosophy
Gaston Bachelard argued that the house “shelters daydreaming”: the attic and cellar of a childhood home stay with us as places to imagine from.
Bachelard, The Poetics of Space (1958)
Chinese fiction Literature
In chapter 5 of Dream of the Red Chamber, Baoyu dreams his way into the Land of Illusion, a palace of cabinets holding registers of the household’s fates.
Cao Xueqin, Dream of the Red Chamber, ch. 5
Exploration notes, not a diagnosis, a prediction, or evidence of real events.
Dreams that share its images
- Would the fall never come to an end? Oxford, England · 1865 (novel)
- Opening Files in a Bright Room Not stated · Date unknown · contemporary study
- The governor who spoke English Spain (dreamed) · before 1911
- Six mirrors in the barber’s shop Tokyo, Japan · 1908
- A video that pauses between dreams Not stated · Date unknown · contemporary study
- Charged one franc of interest Zurich, Switzerland · c. 1914